Cabo Homes Are Selling — They’re Just Taking Longer

by Mitch McDonald & Fletcher Wheaton

Why Overpricing Your Cabo Property Can Cost You Time and Money

One of the most common questions I hear from sellers right now is some version of:

How long should it take to sell my property in Cabo?

The answer is probably longer than many sellers expect.

In the data we recently analyzed, approximately 74% of the homes and condos that actually sold had been on the market for more than 120 days.

That's worth repeating.

These aren't properties that failed to sell.

These are the properties that sold.

And roughly three out of four took more than four months to do it.

Cabo isn't a five-day real estate market

One mistake sellers make is comparing Cabo to the market where they live in the United States or Canada.

Someone might sell a desirable house back home in a week and naturally wonder why their Cabo property hasn't received an offer after 60 days.

But Cabo is primarily a second-home and vacation-home market.

The buyer pool is different.

A buyer might visit Cabo several times before purchasing. They might spend six months comparing Cabo San Lucas with San José del Cabo, the East Cape and the Pacific side. They may also be comparing Cabo with Florida, Hawaii or another second-home destination.

That's very different from someone who needs to buy a primary residence because they're moving across town for a new job or their family needs another bedroom.

The danger isn't necessarily taking four months to sell

The bigger danger is spending those four months at the wrong price.

We've seen this happen repeatedly.

A seller looks at the comparable sales and believes their property deserves a premium.

Maybe they have a better rooftop.

Maybe they spent more on furniture.

Maybe they bought at the top of the market and need a certain number to make the transaction work.

Those things may matter to the seller.

They don't necessarily change what a buyer is willing to pay.

So the property gets listed high.

Nothing happens.

After a few months, the seller reduces the price.

Then they reduce it again.

Eventually, the property gets close to where the comparable sales suggested it should have been priced in the beginning.

Except now it has been sitting on the market for six, nine or twelve months.

That's when buyers start asking questions

Long days on market can change the conversation around a property.

Instead of asking:

"How quickly do we need to make an offer?"

The buyer starts asking:

"Why hasn't this sold?"

That's a completely different negotiating position.

The longer an overpriced property sits, the easier it becomes for buyers to assume that the seller may eventually accept substantially less.

This is what I sometimes call the race to the bottom.

A seller prices high because they don't want to leave money on the table, but the strategy can ultimately create the exact result they were trying to avoid.

Price doesn't have to mean cheap

Pricing correctly doesn't mean giving your property away.

It means looking at what buyers have actually paid for comparable properties and understanding what else is competing with you today.

Those are two different sets of data.

Closed sales tell us what buyers have been willing to pay.

Active listings tell us what a buyer can choose instead of your property.

In a market with more inventory, that second number becomes increasingly important.

The market has actually been improving

There's another important piece of context.

Earlier this year, Los Cabos sales volume was running approximately 25% below the previous year.

In our latest analysis, that gap had narrowed to around 14–15%.

That's meaningful improvement.

So the story isn't that nothing is selling.

Properties are selling, and the market has been closing some of the year-over-year gap.

They're simply taking longer.

Set expectations before putting up the sign

If roughly three-quarters of successful sales are taking more than 120 days, sellers need to build that reality into their strategy from day one.

The conversation shouldn't be:

"How high can we list it?"

It should be:

"Where does the data say we should position this property so that we're one of the properties that actually sells?"

There's a big difference.

In today's Cabo market, patience matters.

But price, positioning and realistic expectations matter even more.

GET MORE INFORMATION

REmexico Real Estate

REmexico Real Estate

Cabo's Best Real Estate Website

+52(624) 218-4534

Name
Phone*
Message